Time borrowing in latches

What is time borrowing: Latches exhibit the property of being transparent when clock is asserted to a required value. In sequential designs, using latches can enhance performace of the design. This is possible due to time borrowing property of latches. We can define time borrowing in latches as follows:

Time borrowing is the property of a latch by virtue of which a path ending at a latch can borrow time from the next path in pipeline such that the overall time of the two paths remains the same. The time borrowed by the latch from next stage in pipeline is, then, subtracted from the next path's time.

The time borrowing property of latches is due to the fact that latches are level sensitive; hence, they can capture data over a range of times than at a single time, the entire duration of time over which they are transparent. If they capture data when they are transparent, the same point of time can launch the data for the next stage (of course, there is combinational delay from data pin of latch to output pin of latch).

Let us consider an example wherein a negative latch is placed between two positive edge-triggered registers for simplicity and ease of understanding. The schematic diagram for the same is shown in figure 1 below:

Figure 1: Negative level-sensitive latch between two positive edge-triggered registers

Figure 2 below shows the clock waveform for all the three elements involved. We have labeled the clock edges for convenience. As is shown, latB is transparent during low phase of the clock. RegA and RegC (positive edge-triggered registers) can capture/launch data only at positive edge of clock; i.e., at Edge1, Edge3 or Edge5. LatB, on other hand, can capture and launch data at any instant of time between Edge2 and Edge3 or Edge4 and Edge5.

Figure 2: Clock waveforms

The time instant at which data is launched from LatB depends upon the time at which data launched from RegA has become stable at the input of latB. If the data launched at Edge1 from RegA gets stable before Edge2, it will get captured at Edge2 itself.  However, if the data is not able to get stable, even then, it will get captured. This time, as soon as the data gets stable, it will get captured. The latest instant of time this can happen is the latch closing edge (Edge3 here). One point here to be noted is that at whatever point data launches from LatB, it has to get captured at RegC at edge3. The more time latch takes to capture the data, it gets subtracted from the next path. The worst case setup check at latB is at edge2. However, latch can borrow time as needed. The maximum time borrowed, ideally, can be upto Edge3. Figure 3 below shows the setup and hold checks with and without time borrow for this case:

Figure 3: Setup check with and without time borrow

The above example consisted of a negative level-sensitive latch. Similarly, a positive level-sensitive latch will also borrow time from the next stage, just the polarities will be different.

Also read:

• Metastability
• Lockup latch - principle, application and timing
• Setup check and hold check for register to latch timing paths
• False paths - basics and example scenarios
• Can hold be frequency dependent

Setup time and hold time basics

In digital designs, each and every flip-flop has some restrictions related to the data with respect to the clock in the form of windows in which data can change or not. There is always a region around the clock edge in which input data should not change at the input of the flip-flop. This is because, if the data changes within this window, we cannot guarantee the output. The output can be the result of either of the previous input, the new input or metastability (as explained in our post  'metastability'). This window is marked by two boundary lines, one pertaining to the setup time of the flop, the other to the hold time defined as below.

Definition of Setup time: Setup time is defined as the minimum amount of time before the clock's active edge that the data must be stable for it to be latched correctly. In other words, each flip-flop (or any sequential element, in general) needs some time for the data to remain stable before the clock edge arrives, such that it can reliably capture the data. This duration is known as setup time.

The data that was launched at the previous clock edge should be stable at the input at least setup time before the clock edge. So, adherence to setup time ensures that the data launched at previous edge is captured properly at the current edge. In other words, we can also say that setup time adherence ensures that the system moves to next state smoothly. 

Definition of Hold time: Hold time is defined as the minimum amount of time after the clock's active edge during which data must be stable. Similar to setup time, each sequential element needs some time for data to remain stable after clock edge arrives to reliably capture data. This duration is known as hold time.

The data that was launched at the current edge should not travel to the capturing flop before hold time has passed after the clock edge. Adherence to hold time ensures that the data launched at current clock edge does not get captured at the same edge. In other words, hold time adherence ensures that system does not deviate from the current state and go into an invalid state.

As shown in the figure 1 below, the data at the input of flip-flop can change anywhere except within the seup time hold time window. 

Figure 1: Setup-hold window

A D-type latch

Cause/origin of setup time and hold time: Setup time and hold time are said to be the backbone of timing analysis. Rightly so, for the chip to function properly, setup and hold timing constraints need to be met properly for each and every flip-flop in the design. If even a single flop exists that does not meet setup and hold requirements for timing paths starting from/ending at it, the design will fail and meta-stability will occur. It is very important to understand the origin of setup time and hold time as whole design functionality is ensured by these. Let us discuss the origin of setup time and hold time taking an example of D-flip-flop as in VLSI designs, D-type flip-flops are almost always used. A D-type flip-flop is realized using two D-type latches; one of them is positive level-sensitive, the other is negative level-sensitive. A D-type latch, in turn, is realized using transmission gates and inverters. Figure below shows a positive-level sensitive D-type latch. Just inverting the transmission gates’ clock, we get negative-level sensitive D-type latch.

A complete D flip-flop using the above structure of D-type latch is shown in figure below:

A D-type flip-flop

Now, let us get into the details of above figure. For data to be latched by ‘latch 1’ at the falling edge of the clock, it must be present at ‘Node F’ at that time. Since, data has to travel ‘NodeA’ -> ‘Node B’ -> ‘Node C’ -> ‘Node D’ -> ‘Node E’ -> ‘Node F’ to reach ‘Node F’, it should arrive at flip-flop’s input (Node A) at some earlier time. This time for data to reach from ‘Node A’ to ‘Node F’ is termed as data setup time (assuming CLK and CLK' are present instantaneously. If that is not the case, it will be accounted for accordingly). Similarly, it is necessary to ensure a stable value at the input to ensure a stable value at ‘Node C’. In other words, hold time can be termed as delay taken by data from ‘Node A’ to ‘Node C’.

Setup and hold checks in a design: Basically, setup and hold timing checks ensure that a data launched from one flop is captured at another properly. Considering the way digital designs of today are designed (finite state machines), the next state is derived from its previous state.  So, data launched at one edge should be captured at next active clock edge. Also, the data launched from one flop should not be captured at next flop at the same edge. These conditions are ensured by setup and hold checks. Setup check ensures that the data is stable before the setup requirement of next active clock edge at the next flop so that next state is reached. Similarly, hold check ensures that data is stable until the hold requirement for the next flop for same clock edge has been met so that present state is not corrupted.

A sample path in a design

Shown above is a flop-to-flop timing path. For simplicity, we have assumed that both the flops are rise edge triggered. The setup and hold timing relations for the data at input of second flop can be explained using the waveforms below:

Figure showing setup and hold checks being applied for the timing path shown above

As shown, data launched from launching flop is allowed to arrive at the input of the second flop only after a delay greater than its hold requirement so that it is properly captured. Similarly, it must not have a delay greater than (clock period – setup requirement of second flop). In other words, mathematically speaking, setup check equation is given as below (assuming zero skew between launch and capture clocks):

                                T_ck->q + T_prop + T_setup < T_period

 Similarly, hold check equation is given as:

                               T_ck->q  + T_{prop >} T_hold

If we take into account skews between the two clocks, the above equations are modified accordingly. If T_skew is the skew between launch and capture flops, (equal to latency of clock at capture flop minus latency of clock at launch flop so that skew is positive if capture flop has larger latency and vice-versa), above equations are modified as below:

                    
                      T_ck->q + T_prop + T_setup - Tskew < T_period

                      T_ck->q  + T_prop > T_hold + T_skew

Setup checks and hold checks for reg-to-reg paths explains different cases covering setup and hold checks for flop-to-flop paths.

What if setup and/or hold violations occur in a design: As said earlier, setup and hold timings are to be met in order to ensure that data launched from one flop is captured properly at the next flop at next clock edge so as to transfer the state-machine of the design to the next state. If the setup check is violated, the data will not be captured at the next clock edge properly. Similarly, if hold check is violated, data intended to be captured at the next edge will get captured at the same edge. Setup hold violations can also lead to data changing within setup/hold window of the capturing flip-flop. It may lead to metastability failure in the design (as explained in our post 'metastability'). So, it is necessary to have setup and hold requirements met for all the flip-flops in the design and there should not be any setup/hold violation.

What if you fabricate a design without taking care of setup/hold violations: If you fabricate a design having setup violations, you can still use it by lowering the frequency as the equation involves the variable clock frequency. On the other hand, a design with hold violation cannot be run properly. So, if you fabricate a design with an accidental hold violation, you will have to simply throw away the chip (unless the hold path is half cycle as explained here). A design with half cycle hold violations only can still be used at lower frequencies.

Tackling setup time violation:  As given above, the equation for setup timing check is given as:
            T_ck->q + T_prop + T_setup - T_skew < T_period

The parameter that represents if there is a setup time violation is setup slack. The setup slack can be defined as the difference between the L.H.S and R.H.S. In other words, it is the margin that is available such that the timing path meets setup check. The setup slack equation can be given as:
            Setup slack = T_period -  (T_ck->q + T_prop + T_setup - T_skew)
If setup slack is positive, it means there is still some margin available in the timing path. On the other hand, a negative slack means that the paths violates setup timing check by the amount of setup slack. To get the path met, either data delay should be decreased or clock period should be increased.

Mitigating setup violation: Thus, we can meet the setup requirement, if violating, by 

1. Decreasing clk->q delay of launching flop 

2. Decreasing the propagation delay of the combinational cloud 

3. Reducing the setup time requirement of capturing flop 

4. Increasing the skew between capture and launch clocks

5. Increasing the clock period

Tackling hold time violation: Similarly, the equation for hold timing check is as below:

            T_ck->q + T_prop > T_hold + T_skew

The parameter that represents if there is a hold timing violation is hold slack. The hold slack is defined as the amount by which L.H.S is greater than R.H.S. In other words, it is the margin by which timing path meets the hold timing check. The equation for hold slack is given as:
            Hold slack = T_ck->q + T_{prop -} T_hold - T_skew
If hold slack is positive, it means there is still some margin available before it will start violating for hold. A negative hold slack means the path is violating hold timing check by the amount represented by hold slack. To get the path met, either data path delay should be increased, or clock skew/hold requirement of capturing flop should be decreased.

Mitigating hold violation: We can meet the hold requirement by:

1. Increasing the clk->q delay of launching flop
2. Decreasing the hold requirement of capturing flop
3.  Decreasing clock skew between capturing clock and launching flip-flops

Also read:

• Power aware RTL design
• Data checks - data setup check and data hold check
• Metal ECO - the process
• Build a latch using a 2:1 mux